Filmmakers Jesse Moss and Amanda McBaine embark on their second venture documenting teenagers engaging in mock democratic setups with the release of Girls State, a companion to their acclaimed 2020 documentary Boys State. This unique leadership program challenges adolescents to establish their own state, complete with a governor, municipal council, and even a mock Supreme Court.
Describing this exercise as democracy in its purest form, Jesse refers to it as the “worst form of democracy training, except for all the others that there are.” According to him, Girls State provides a rare space for individuals of diverse political beliefs to engage in meaningful dialogue and gain firsthand experience of democratic mechanisms. Amanda emphasizes the effectiveness of the program’s “learn-by-doing” approach, wherein participants tackle real issues within a simulated environment.
Shot against the backdrop of the United States grappling with the looming possibility of Roe v. Wade being overturned, Girls State delves into the deliberations of young girls on abortion-related cases. Beyond mere moral debates, the film explores the intricacies of legal battles such as the Dobbs case.
For Nisha Murali, one of the teenagers featured in the documentary, Girls State offers an opportunity to establish common ground among participants before delving into political divides. However, Jesse observes flaws in the program, noting that girls are initially cautious and lack the same freedom as boys to dive into politics.
Gender segregation emerges as a pertinent issue in the film, prompting questions about integration. While acknowledging the benefits of women-only spaces, Nisha advocates for ongoing integration efforts. Yet, she recognizes the initial value of women coming together to overcome shared barriers to political representation.
The documentary captures the camaraderie and political aspirations of the teenagers, a feat made possible through months of casting and close collaboration with the participants. Each cast member was paired with a dedicated cameraperson, fostering a sense of comfort and trust in front of the lens.
Amanda reflects on the unexpected support and encouragement that blossomed among the ambitious participants, challenging stereotypes of teenage behavior. For Nisha, Girls State served as a lesson in resilience and adaptation, shaping her perspective beyond political ambitions.
In documenting this transformative experience, Jesse sees parallels with the unpredictable nature of documentary filmmaking, highlighting the potential for personal growth and revelation. Ultimately, Girls State offers a poignant exploration of youth, ambition, and the transformative power of shared experiences.
